Policy by trial and error: how Silicon Valley culture has infiltrated governments
Fleur Johns, Dean and Head of School, University of Sydney Law School, University of Sydney United States foreign policymaking under the second Trump administration is frequently described as erratic and incoherent. We’ve seen the launch of trade wars and actual wars, all without consulting allies first. This administration advances foreign policy through trial actions that are adjusted or abandoned, depending on what happens. The administration has a political vision, but many decisions are not easily reconciled with it. Trump’s approach is not, however, idiosyncratic or perverse. It’s an extreme expression of a decades-long broader shift in governance around the world, including in Australia. Trump’s foreign policy is symptomatic of a turn towards governance by prototype, an approach that is traceable to Silicon Valley. But governments aren’t in charge of products or websites. The mistakes of government can cost, at best, huge amounts of taxpayer money, or at worst, human lives. ‘Prototyping’ policy Governance by prototype is a way of exercising power that relies less on comprehensive strategies and long-term plans, and more on rapid rollout and fast feedback. Prototyping, in this sense, means deploying partial and temporary interventions designed to generate information quickly about what “works”. These prototypes are not policies in the traditional sense. They are intentionally incomplete measures, such as experimental diplomatic signals, test communications, or what commentators sometimes call “minimally viable” policies, borrowing from business development lingo. They are developed just enough to be put into use so governments can see how people react. Many examples of prototyping in policy take the form of digital applications or measures introduced by bypassing full parliamentary or congressional votes. The COVIDSafe app was delivered quickly, but ultimately did little to help contact tracing.David Hunt/AAP In Australia, the CovidSafe app is one noteworthy example from the past decade. In the United States, Trump’s […]
